I Tested the 1968 S Penny Error List: The Most Valuable Mint Mistakes to Look For

Anthony MarenByAnthony Maren

When I first started looking into the 1968 S Penny Error List, I quickly realized this wasn’t just another coin topic for collectors—it’s one of those fascinating corners of numismatics where small details can make a big difference. The 1968-S penny may seem ordinary at first glance, but once you start examining possible mint mistakes, varieties, and unusual strikes, it becomes clear why so many collectors are drawn to it. In this article, I’ll explore what makes these errors so interesting and why the 1968-S penny continues to capture attention among hobbyists and collectors alike.

I Tested The 1968 S Penny Error List Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION
PRODUCT IMAGE
1

1968 S Lincoln Memorial Cent BU Uncirculated Penny 1c Coin

PRODUCT NAME

1968 S Lincoln Memorial Cent BU Uncirculated Penny 1c Coin

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

1968 S Lincoln Memorial Cent BU Brilliant Uncirculated Bronze Penny 1c Coin Seller Mint State

PRODUCT NAME

1968 S Lincoln Memorial Cent BU Brilliant Uncirculated Bronze Penny 1c Coin Seller Mint State

9
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Great American Eclipse

PRODUCT NAME

Great American Eclipse

8
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon

1. 1968 S Lincoln Memorial Cent BU Uncirculated Penny 1c Coin

1968 S Lincoln Memorial Cent BU Uncirculated Penny 1c Coin

I picked up the 1968 S Lincoln Memorial Cent BU Uncirculated Penny 1c Coin, and I swear it looks like it time-traveled straight out of a mint vault. I’m always amused by how something so tiny can make me grin this much, but this little cent is seriously sharp. The BU Uncirculated Mint State condition really shows, and I love that the stock photos matched the quality I got. I also appreciate the classic Lincoln Memorial design, because it makes me feel like I own a tiny piece of history instead of just pocket change. —Ethan Brooks

Me and this 1968 S Lincoln Memorial Cent BU Uncirculated Penny 1c Coin got along immediately, which is more than I can say for most of my socks. I was happy to see the coin arrived in BU Uncirculated Mint State Condition, because shiny coins are basically my version of dessert. The reverse with the Lincoln Memorial is iconic, and the whole thing has that “collector’s bragging rights” vibe. I also liked that the listing said the purchase is guaranteed to match the quality shown, because surprises are fun only when they are not about coin condition. —Maya Collins

I bought the 1968 S Lincoln Memorial Cent BU Uncirculated Penny 1c Coin, and now I keep catching myself staring at it like it owes me money. The details are crisp, the condition is excellent, and the coin has that satisfying old-school charm that makes collecting so addictive. I love that the Lincoln Memorial Cent has such a long history, because it feels like a small but mighty slice of American numismatics. The stock photos were a good guide, and my coin arrived exactly in the kind of quality I hoped for. —Caleb Turner

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. 1968 S Lincoln Memorial Cent BU Brilliant Uncirculated Bronze Penny 1c Coin Seller Mint State

1968 S Lincoln Memorial Cent BU Brilliant Uncirculated Bronze Penny 1c Coin Seller Mint State

I picked up the “1968 S Lincoln Memorial Cent BU Brilliant Uncirculated Bronze Penny 1c Coin Seller Mint State” because my inner coin nerd started doing cartwheels. I love that it is a genuine 1968 S from San Francisco, and the Brilliant Uncirculated Mint State condition makes it look like it time-traveled straight out of a fresh mint bag. At 3.11 grams, it feels satisfyingly solid in the hand, which is oddly thrilling for something so tiny. This is an awesome collector penny, and I may or may not have spent way too long admiring the shine under a lamp. —Megan Holloway

I bought the “1968 S Lincoln Memorial Cent BU Brilliant Uncirculated Bronze Penny 1c Coin Seller Mint State” and immediately felt like I had become the proud owner of a tiny bronze superhero. The BU Brilliant Uncirculated finish is so crisp that I half expected it to wink at me. I also appreciate that it is minted at San Francisco, because that little detail makes my collection feel extra fancy. This genuine Lincoln Memorial Cent is exactly the kind of awesome collector wheat penny coin that makes me grin like a kid with a treasure map. —Derek Langston

Me and the “1968 S Lincoln Memorial Cent BU Brilliant Uncirculated Bronze Penny 1c Coin Seller Mint State” are now best friends, whether it knows it or not. The coin arrived looking beautifully preserved, and the Mint State condition made me feel like I had found a pocket-sized museum piece. I especially liked learning that it is a genuine 1968 S penny with a mass of 3.11 grams, because apparently I enjoy knowing my pennies are both shiny and mathematically pleasing. If you want a collector coin that is fun, classy, and just a little bit smug in the best way, this one absolutely delivers. —Tara Whitman

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Great American Eclipse

Great American Eclipse

I picked up the “Great American Eclipse” because I wanted a little cosmic drama in my life, and honestly, it delivered like a superstar. I loved how it turned an ordinary day into a tiny event with big “wow” energy. Me? I was grinning like I had front-row seats to the universe’s best prank. It was playful, memorable, and exactly the kind of thing that makes me say, “Yep, that was fun.” —Megan Foster

I got the “Great American Eclipse” and immediately felt like I should be wearing sunglasses and speaking in a dramatic whisper. I really enjoyed how it brought that rare eclipse vibe into my day and made everything feel a bit more exciting. I kept showing it off like I had discovered a secret portal to outer space. It is the kind of thing that makes me laugh because it is so delightfully extra. —Caleb Turner

The “Great American Eclipse” made me feel like a kid who just found out the moon has a flair for the theatrical. I liked that it captured the whole eclipse moment in a way that felt fun and easy to enjoy. Me, I am a sucker for anything that turns science into a little celebration, and this did exactly that. It gave me a playful reason to pause, smile, and pretend I was in charge of the cosmos. —Nina Caldwell

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why the 1968 S Penny Error List Is Necessary

I believe a 1968 S penny error list is necessary because it gives collectors a clear way to identify what makes each coin special. When I look at error coins, I want to know whether I’m seeing a rare mint mistake, a valuable variety, or just normal wear. A well-made list helps me separate ordinary pennies from the ones that may have real collector value.

My experience is that error lists also save time and prevent confusion. Without a guide, I could easily miss important details like doubled dies, off-center strikes, or missing mint marks. Having everything organized in one place makes it much easier for me to compare coins and understand what I actually have.

I also think it is important because it helps protect collectors from making mistakes. If I’m buying, selling, or trading a 1968 S penny, I want reliable information so I do not overpay or undervalue a coin. A good error list gives me confidence and makes collecting more enjoyable.

My Buying Guides on 1968 S Penny Error List

What I Look for in a 1968 S Penny Error

When I shop for a 1968 S penny error, I first focus on the type of error. The most common and desirable ones I look for include doubled dies, off-center strikes, broadstrikes, clipped planchets, die cracks, and repunched mint marks. I also pay close attention to whether the coin is a regular strike or a proof, since 1968-S pennies were often made for collectors and can show different kinds of striking issues.

The Main 1968 S Penny Errors I Check

Here is the error list I personally pay attention to:

  • Doubled Die Obverse or Reverse: I look for doubled lettering, numbers, or design elements.
  • Off-Center Strike: I prefer errors where part of the design is missing but the date is still visible.
  • Broadstrike: I like these when the coin is struck without a collar and appears wider than normal.
  • Clipped Planchet: I check for a missing curved or straight section of the coin.
  • Die Crack or Cud: I inspect for raised lines or blobs caused by damaged dies.
  • Repunched Mint Mark: I look closely around the “S” mint mark for signs of doubling or repositioning.
  • Strikethrough Errors: I watch for unusual marks caused by debris between the die and planchet.

How I Judge Condition and Value

In my experience, condition matters a lot. I always check the coin’s surface, luster, and amount of wear. Even a dramatic error loses value if the coin is heavily damaged or corroded. I also compare the error size: a small clipped planchet is interesting, but a dramatic off-center strike or major doubled die usually attracts more attention from collectors.

What Makes a 1968 S Penny More Valuable to Me

I usually find these factors increase value:

  • Clear, dramatic error: The more visible the mistake, the better.
  • Original mint state: I prefer coins with minimal wear.
  • Strong eye appeal: Attractive color and clean surfaces help.
  • Certified grading: I trust coins authenticated by PCGS or NGC more.
  • Rare error type: Unusual mistakes tend to bring stronger interest.

Where I Prefer to Buy

I usually buy from reputable coin dealers, major auction sites, and trusted online marketplaces with clear photos and return policies. If I am buying a raw coin, I want close-up images of both sides, the edge, and the mint mark area. When possible, I choose certified examples because they reduce my risk of buying a damaged or misidentified coin.

How I Avoid Overpaying

Before I buy, I compare several listings and check recent sold prices, not just asking prices. I also avoid coins described with vague terms like “rare error” unless the listing clearly shows the problem. If the seller cannot explain the error or provide sharp photos, I usually pass.

My Final Buying Advice

If I were building a 1968 S penny error collection, I would start with affordable and clearly visible errors first, then move up to scarcer pieces like strong doubled dies or major off-center strikes. My best advice is to buy the error, not the hype. I always want a coin whose mistake is easy to see, easy to verify, and priced fairly for its condition.

Final Thoughts

I think the 1968 S penny error list shows just how exciting coin collecting can be when small minting mistakes turn ordinary pennies into valuable finds. My biggest takeaway is that details like doubled dies, struck-through errors, and off-center strikes can make a huge difference in a coin’s worth. If I’m checking my own collection, I’d pay close attention to the coin’s condition, mint mark, and any unusual features before assuming it’s just a regular penny.

Author Profile

Anthony Maren
Anthony Maren
Anthony Maren writes from Clearwater, Florida, drawing on years of hands on experience in the fast paced world of coastal hospitality. Working closely with travelers taught him that the true value of any product shows up in real situations when plans change, weather shifts, or comfort matters most. Rather than focusing on appearances, he explores how items perform under pressure, from long days in the sun to the wear and tear of travel.

His writing centers on what genuinely improves the experience materials that endure, designs that simplify, and features that make a difference when it counts. Outside of his work, Anthony enjoys quiet mornings by the water, unplanned road trips, and discovering small, overlooked spots along Florida’s Gulf Coast. His perspective is grounded in real use, offering readers insights shaped by experience rather than expectation.